
Media Centres, high tech, LED lit, video recording goodness in a box have become the the biggest must have item in home technology. VHS is long gone, DVD recorders were (and still are) an ill-concieved idea. But media centres, with large hard drives, attractive user interfaces and power to boot are right where domestic tech should be - useful, easy to use and attractive.
Processing power however is not usually mentioned in discussions surrounding media centres. Largely because if the job gets done, smoothly, efficiently and without the blue screen of death threatening to appear most people 't really care how many processors are housed in their aluminum cases.
Valens Quin latest post over at
The Gadget Guy makes some points on the contrary:
Let’s face it, enlisting a fully-fledged dual-processor Windows XP computer for recording TV, storing photos, music and video, is like stuffing an F1 engine into a lawnmower. Considering there are dedicated products such as hard disk-equipped personal video recorders (PVRs) that do just about the same thing for around $700, compared to about $2,000 for this unit, why would you bother?
The unit in question is Optiva's Vi4. The unit packs a punch with a dual core 2.8GHz processor, 1Gb RAM, 250GB HDD and dual layer DVD burner. With so much power on hand Quin's main gripe was the heat output (while her quasi-enviro warrior side harked on about energy wastage).
In my mind at least heat output falls far below the expense concern. Why, if all you wish to do is record some telly, store and display your digital photos and occasionally browse the net would you want to fork out 2,000 big ones? Surely a standard desktop PC serves as a better, more expedient platform for all the services media centres such as these offer minus the recording function.
Save you money, buy a PVR (or Xbox for that matter) and invest the savings in a decent PC that you will actually use.